!
6 3 ( % * 4 0 ' % ( 6 ( . & " 4 # ) % " ( 6 - ( " - % - % 0 7 6 % " $ ,
."&)*7!"0.&*%2(!/"%(+*$%6&77%$)&.!(2)"/!%"58#"%$(!51!%2(!/%68(7%<4!&1%-%3&8&8$%6!.87%,6&4!')5$%&1(-%6"&#6
&61+$%1973-7%.3&-!5&"%6!&.1!6%#!6&+7%&8&"8%(/!6!%,3&4-5$%6/(!$7%,*!.%&.8%(/!6%,$)&.!(2)"/%6*-.$7%&.8!%9!8/(%(/!6
.3&5-)65%3&(/6"%3&2.-!2*%40%&6&#.$%.-5"5!%3&2.-!2*%$#.5%&./%3!&$%30%.6!/"50"%&68(+%2003-7!%,$)"#57%"0*%(7#"
.6&5-)/$%&6"18$%68&1(7%&6!/%$#.$8%!)$%$:%.6&0!0-+%6!&#5!5"%91!6%6!&#5!5%9&7%7!"&87%$7(%6!7&8#%&6&/(%-&565!%:/5
(/65$%(+*%67&61!%,(
Facet Theory
)%6!#28$%6(!6%;5*%"4%3&-!5&"%6!&.1!6%6&&.7"%3&&2(!/&6$%6!-!*&$%#!6&+%:6&()&4$%&65!(6
.6/:
* $ ( 8 " ( 3 - 0 " ( 3 % 0 7 & 6 % - % 5 & . ) " ( . 3 ( 8
2.(2.&/%&(6/!%-!5&"%&(+*%,-!5&"%6!&.1!6%#!6&+7%6)*!4!%,'7%"54%6""157%"!$&.!%$&846%6*-.$%6505%8/(%68585%&./
.$:%3!#67%3&(!5%61(-$7%91!%"!$&.!%$&&846%6*-.$%6!4!')5"%3&78)!65
.$:%4!')57%(50%2)&!(+%4!'&7%"4%$&6!1"8$7!%,"!$&.!%$&&846%6*-.$%6/(!$7%"7#!(%65!4"%)5!4"%65"&-7%)*4%&"8%2(!2)!-$
.6&*-.$-6&61(45%$7&8#%6&&.7$"%(50$%2)&!(+%65!(6%6/%)-!7%()#5$
!
" ) " ( % " ( 7 & # % " ( 6 - ( " - % - % 0 7 6 % " $ ,
9!.16%6!1(45)%&8&"8%(/!6!%6&61"55$%$2&*(7&.!/7%$)&25657%&.8%(/!6%&65&&*%38%,$&*!(7%"/(!/%6(&7%,0(!7.&(2)&7%&6-5"
&6#+85%34%&6&"4%1990%6.87%.2.'!-"%&6&.!5!%"/(!/%"8%$&&(1"%$&5-)/7%&6-74%.6&0!"!.12$%$2&*(7&.!/7%(78#5%6(:47
()#5%6&541%9!&.127%&6-74%1991-6%3&.87%.(6!.!15/$&0!"!.12)%9!&.127!%($)&2565)%3&.(!/7%$/(!$%6-!46%&65"8$%,"/(8&"
.$)"#57%"0*%(7#%&./%1996%6.85%.$)&2565"%$2"!)+7%$!!".%$'(51!%,3&4-5$!%$&0!"!.12$%6/(!$"%$)"#57
$&0!"!.12$%&-!5&"%3!-&)7%-%$)&2!7!($%3!#67%.3&5!#6%&.87%3&#6+65!%,6&0!"!.12%$&&84!%&4-5%()#%;!65%$-&5"7%3&)*!4%&()#5
;!.&#$%3!#67%.3"!47!%<(/7%3&2!7!(%6!&!(#6%9!0(/!%$)&2)-&-%#!6&+%""!1%,3&2!7!(%6"4+$!%$&&.7%,9167%6!*.6$%;!65%3&4-5$!
.6!/2&*(7&.!/7%3&(!5%6(81$7!%3&&2565%-!*&%6!4!')5%6/(!$7%3&&6!7(6-7(!%3&&5!8&&%3&27&$7%-)565%&./%&2565$
" ( # 4 % * " ' % " " 8 % - % ( " $ 1 $ ) % 5 & . ) " ( . 3 ( 8
,6&67&7*! 6&#(:/%$*-.$"%$2"!)+$)%9!&.127%9!8/($%(/!6$%3!&*%(#/"%.;!.&#%6.&')1%""$'7%&66(&8!%,"/!58%64707%&6-"!.
;!.&#"!%7!'&4"%&5-)/$%:1(57%$#.5!%$'(5%&./%3!&1!%,2(!2)!-!%&.8%(/!6%&65"8$%;85$7%.6!&')!(2*.!)%9!.167%&6-74%(1976
.9!&.127%3&4-5$!%$&0!"!.12$%6/(!$"%$)"#57%6&!!".%$(&17%$'(5%68585!%,$(!2)2&1(/"%$)"#57%,$+&#%!'&!
.
3&"1&(-/"%&5!8&&%&"11%$)&2565%-!5&""%6&.1!6%6!.7"!%,$)&25655%6!"1&(-/%&-&5"6%"8%$4&6($%6/%00!+"%-4!.%&"8%()#5$
!
& 3 6 $ 0 6 : % 5 & " ( # % " ( 6 - ( " - % - % 0 7 6 % 5 " $ ,
2(!2)!-%2*!+%;9!&.12$5%&2565%;!.&#7%&8&"8!%&.8%3&(/6!%,3&"8!(&7%6&(74$%$2&*(7&.!/$5%$)&25657%9!8/(%(/!6%6(0!7%&./
3&2)&!(+%6"$.5%&.-!4!%&6"$&.%$.8%20-1%;857!%,&-!*&-"4%(+*%6&77%$)&2565%&6-5&"%.(
LRDC
)%0(!7*2&+%62&*(7&.!/7%&6&84
6!.&!'5!%&!'&5"%6&.1!6$%8/(7%6-5!4%&./%.$)&2565"%3&(!5-&(!5%"8!%3&(!5%"8%6&4!')5%6!#6+6$7%3&)*!4$%,)&$%&7#(
."/(8&7%
PISA
%()#5%"8%&!0&$$%6-4!%("!&%68585!%-%;!.&#$%-(85%"8%&-!*&-"4%;!.&#"%,0/$%"8%"0-$%6.&+*%-%"$)&25657
6)!"#5%6!((!45$%6!5&85%"8%94727%;3&(!5%"8!%3&-&5"6%"8%6&2565$%$7&8#7!%$.7$7%6!/50!-%"8%95!)57%3&)*!4%&&()#5
.$)&2565"%3&(!5-&(!5!%3&(!5%"8%$-&5"%&1&"$67!%;$/(!$%&#(+!%3&(!5%"8%6&0!0-+$!%6&2565$%$.7$$%6)54$"%6!1&"!5!
,
JMTE
%64$%761%"8%6-#!&5%$(!-$5%61&(4%;&2565$%;!.&#$%3!#67%3&"&7!5%3&(!5-&(!5%"8%#!6&+!%$(81$%:6&()&4$%&65!(6
.$)&2565"%3&(!5%"8%6!#6+6$$!%$(81$$%;&"$67%6!&2565%6!5&85%"8%9-&)+6!%9472%:/8!.7%,$.85%61(!4%68585%&./%!78
3 & 8 ( : - / ( , ) 5 % 6 & " & # % " " 8 % - % ( " $ 1 $ ) % 5 & . ) " ( . 3 ( 8
#!+&27%3&)*!4$%,&2565$%;!.&#$%3!#67%3&2)&!(+%"8%6&4-5%6:1(%&./%%3!&1%.9!&.127%&2565%;!.&#7%3&(/6%$8!"8%&6-5"
.$/(!$7%$&0!"!.12%6!7"85$%6!&.1!67!%(+*%&677%3&&.!0(/%3&&!.&8%6"7!$7%&6)*4%(747%.$1(-$!%-!5&"%&(5!#%#!6&+!%6!.&!'5
6!/50!-7%)!*&4$8%$-&5"$%6!&!.5-:$!%,3$&6!6&17%6!&2565%6!/50!-7%3&(!5%"8%8!5&8!%$(&#7%&1(-7%)*4%&"8%2(!2)!-$
3&(!5%"8%6&4!')5%6!#6+6$!%$(81$"%6!&.1!6%(!+&8"%()#5$%&/'55%3&5(!6%6&2(!/&6$%$5!(6"%,*!.7%.3$&.+7%#6!+
.3&-&5"6"%-!5&"%&(5!#%#!6&+"%30%!51%,6!/50!-%"8%6"18!5%$(&#7%"8%(8)$7%$)&2565"
10
47...,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1